Which free Shopify size chart is worth it past three products?

A furniture shop with forty sofas does not want a watermark on the size chart, and it does not want a second invoice the day the fourth chart goes live. “Free” on an App Store card is not that answer. On 11 November 2026 I opened the live listings for OO ‑ Advanced Table Builder, Kiwi Size Chart & Recommender, and Tably Comparison & Spec Tables, plus Translate table content and What is Tables, Specs & Comparisons?. Both docs say they were updated about two months ago.

The 2 November scorecard weighed five table types together. This one weighs a narrower bill: a free size chart once the catalog is larger than three products and the brand will not carry a watermark. Recompute it if OO grows a paid card, if Kiwi Free drops the watermark or the publish cap, or if Tably prints a size chart on its own card.

Knockouts before the average

A missing must-have removes an app from this question even when the weighted number looks tidy.

Tably is out as a size chart before the total matters. Kiwi Free is out if a watermark or a three-chart cap is a real requirement. The matrix below is still there so the weights can be checked. The winner of this question is whoever survives the rows above.

Weights for this bill

These weights are for a catalog past three products that refuses a watermark. They are not the 2 November weights.

Scores run from 1 to 5 on this morning’s cards. “Not on the card” is not a 5, and it is not proof the feature is missing. It is a low score because it cannot be cited.

The three cards

OO ‑ Advanced Table Builder. Free. No second card. No Built for Shopify line in the header (the phrase did not appear before pricing). 5.0 from 1 review. The card is 24 September 2026, Industrial Garden, Netherlands, about 20 hours using the app, Dutch text about specifications and comparisons. No reply on this screen. Launched 17 September 2026. Listing language: English. Works with Admin, AI, Excel, and Google Sheets. Resources: privacy policy and FAQ, no App Documentation row in this fetch. The hero names size charts, specs, comparison tables, tabbed content, and Us vs Them, a visual builder or an AI draft from text or a screenshot, metafields, and translating customer-facing text. The overview article confirms popup or inline charts, optional diagrams, and more than one chart. The translation article says “merchant-facing strings”, only strings from the current structure, and a revisit after a structure change. Examples: titles, labels, trigger text, empty-state. No auto-translate in that article. No publish cap on the listing. That is not a fit recommender. The listing does not have one.

Kiwi Size Chart & Recommender. No Built for Shopify line in the header this morning. 4.7 from 1,241 reviews (a check yesterday read 1,242). Histogram: fives 87 percent, bucket shown as 1.1K; 78 fours (6 percent); 28 threes (2 percent); 19 twos (2 percent); 37 ones (3 percent). A visible critical card: 19 October 2026, Jokers Costume Mega, metadata filters no longer work after about five years, and they are looking for an alternative. The Magic summary, shown once an app has 100 or more reviews, describes years of use and fast support. Free: publish up to 3 charts, responsive, 22 templates, unlimited CSV, import from the product description, watermark included. $7.99: up to 10 charts, no watermark, analytics, auto-translate EN and ES, 14-day trial, “no additional monthly charges”, optional import credits. $14.99: up to 20 charts, up to 10 recommenders, auto-translate EN, ES, NL, FR, DE, and IT, extra charges on order volume. $26.99: unlimited charts and recommenders, 22 languages, the same volume line. The recommender is a real strength. It does not start on Free.

Tably. Built for Shopify in the header. 3.3 from 5 reviews (four fives, one one). The three cards on screen are positive: 31 October 2025 The Royal Portraits, 13 October Simpsonize Me, 31 October SlothBedding. The one-star text was not on those cards. Launched 8 October 2025. One card: $6.99 a month or $55 a year (save 34 percent), 14-day trial. Unlimited tables, compare on product and collection pages, specs from variants and metafields, “Us vs Them”, shareable links, Tably AI, colors, mobile. Metaobjects are in the description. Size charts are not on this card. A later block on the page mentions size charts on other apps. That is a different listing.

The prices and the “3 charts” line come from the Kiwi and Tably cards. “No cap” on the figure means the OO listing does not print a publish cap. It is not a contract sentence from the docs.

Weighted scores

OO’s sum: 4.5×30 + 5×20 + 5×15 + 4×10 + 2×10 + 3×10 + 3×5 = 415, divided by 100. Kiwi: 60+40+15+20+50+30+20 = 235. Tably: 30+80+60+20+25+40+15 = 270. OO’s 4.5 on the size chart is not a 5: one review does not prove scale, and “no cap printed” is not a docs sentence that says unlimited. Kiwi’s 2 is the Free card, not the $14.99 recommender. Tably’s 4 on other tables is fair: compare, specs, us vs them, and metaobjects are on the card. The 1 on size charts is fair too.

Kiwi wins the reviews and, once you pay, the recommender and auto-translate. $7.99 removes the watermark and lifts the cap to 10. Dutch sits on $14.99, with order-volume charges. Tably wins the badge and the comparison table, and loses this question because the card is not a size chart. OO wins the free step past three products, on the cards as they stood this morning.

When a page is enough

One static chart that changes twice a year can live on a page or in a product metafield. That is not a popup beside Add to cart, it does not translate per locale, and it does not become a specs panel. The line between a metafield and a builder is the 4 November note. Forty sizes, or a chart that also has to carry specifications and a comparison, is past that page.

Sources

• OO ‑ Advanced Table Builder listing.

• Kiwi Size Chart & Recommender listing.

• Tably listing.

• Translate table content.

• What is Tables, Specs & Comparisons?.

On this site

The earlier scorecard, on different weights, is here. How the locale row works is the 9 November note. Which block you place is the 1 November checklist. The app page is Advanced Table Builder. Shopify apps as a service: apps and integrations.

What still holds on 11 November 2026

For a free size chart past three products, without a watermark, OO Free is the only one of these three that survives the must-haves. The total is 4.15 against 2.35 and 2.70, on weights that make that free step heavy. Kiwi is the better pick once a recommender or auto-translate is the requirement, and that card is no longer free. Install from this listing when the free step is the question: OO ‑ Advanced Table Builder. Recalculate if Kiwi Free loses the watermark, or if this listing grows a price.